Even with the Pilot Sports available now in an all season option I still decided to go with another set of these has I had zero issues with them.
34.1KVIEWS
77REPLIES
53APPRECIATES
37ACTIVE PEOPLE
05-03-2026LAST POST
Even with the Pilot Sports available now in an all season option I still decided to go with another set of these has I had zero issues with them.
My LCI 2025 X5MC:
Just installed the Arroyo’s for winter driving and on day 2. Tires need to “break in” for traction. Noticed big positive difference in “comfort” ride over road bumps versus the PS4’s. On the highway I feel a little less confident and I noticed a lot of “wiggle” when shifting the steering wheel right to left quickly. Not sure if the softer support sidewalls are the culprit but it definitely doesn’t feel as confident for cornering or sudden wheel movements. Granted it’s been one day and only 40 miles of highway driving. Hoping they “break in” and offer more solid highway/cornering performance.
If they don’t improve I may consider the more expensive and new PS4 All Season to compare. If anyone has done that I would love to hear their experience.
Paid a total of $700 for all four Arroyo Grand Sport A/S in OEM size for the X5MC. Shocked that Discount Tire charged $240 to swap tires from the PS4’s to Arroyo’s even though they balanced perfectly. They only charge $112.50 if the tires are bought from them or Tire Rack… hmmm.
Vyper340 wroteWhy not consider the Conti DW06+? Many satisfied users on here that have swapped. Also they'll be slightly "cheaper" than the A/S PS4s but def more than what you paid for they Arroyo.Loop not closed
My LCI 2025 X5MC:
Just installed the Arroyo’s for winter driving and on day 2. Tires need to “break in” for traction. Noticed big positive difference in “comfort” ride over road bumps versus the PS4’s. On the highway I feel a little less confident and I noticed a lot of “wiggle” when shifting the steering wheel right to left quickly. Not sure if the softer support sidewalls are the culprit but it definitely doesn’t feel as confident for cornering or sudden wheel movements. Granted it’s been one day and only 40 miles of highway driving. Hoping they “break in” and offer more solid highway/cornering performance.
If they don’t improve I may consider the more expensive and new PS4 All Season to compare. If anyone has done that I would love to hear their experience.
Paid a total of $700 for all four Arroyo Grand Sport A/S in OEM size for the X5MC. Shocked that Discount Tire charged $240 to swap tires from the PS4’s to Arroyo’s even though they balanced perfectly. They only charge $112.50 if the tires are bought from them or Tire Rack… hmmm.
jml721bmw wroteI've had mine on for 1-1/2 years, ~15,000 miles and no issues whatsoever including high speed, rain, snow, you name it... tread is still goodI’m really interested in getting these tires. I have continentals on it right now and the noise is loud and the rolling distance is terrible. Are these actually worth buying or am I gonna be disappointed?
No knock on the Arroyo’s just didn’t want to wait 4 days for a tire.
