If you want performance and practicality:
GLA45 AMG or Macan (less room than golf R though)
Golf R or R400 if they bring it
Focus RS
Utility: I'd say Grand Cherokee Overland V-8 or Summit or New XC90 T6
Sedan: Charger Scat pack (or Hellcat
), SS (not a fan of how it looks but performance is there)
S4 is going to be redesigned soon and while its a good car its dated.