You like German cars so maybe you like German watches.
For folks who want a manufacture watch or folks who want something non-manufacture but different without being "out there," Damasko is an interesting brand. They offer watches with ETA and ETA/Valjoux movements as well as their own movements. Their products are all very well crafted and engineered. Price range: $1100 - $4500. (straps and bracelets available)
Their website is a pleasure to visit, which is not something I think about a great many watch companies. It's well ordered, provides comprehensive details about the products, including the price, and pictures that are neither too large nor too small. Also, it doesn't have any of that "wonky" animation and fancy Flash that so many upper tier brands do.
