[nZtiZia]

Originally Posted by smomin23

You might not have an answer for this, but since you have had both types of units, do you believe the button still can be pulled? Leaving the ring in place but just pulling the middle button itself.

i can't say for sure since i never had to deal with the button either on my original unit or the replacement. i would attempt removing the ring first, though, since its removal makes it easier to remove the button.

[smomin23]

It is installed!

Firstly, I want to apologize for not posting yesterday. I got the rubber on time but couldn't get make time to take a whack at it.

So a few things I learned in this process:

1. Sticky rubber that Martin (from Car Analysis) so generously provided after I reached out isn't tacky enough to pull the button. I tried multiple times by forming the rubber, letting it set for 5-10 minutes, the holding the volume assembly in (by gripping the ring, bare handed), and yanking the button with the other hand.

2. You can complete this task without removing the ring at all. This was the assumption but I can confirm.

I ended up using a tiny screwdriver. Very gently shimmied it in between the button and the ring near the L and pried. It did slip a bit but I was very cautious and gentle and the clip did let go. Then I simply worked my way around 180° (similar to how the instruction video is) while prying.

My flathead was damaged (see pics) and wouldn't be good for anything else but me being a hoarder paid off! That said, pretty sure you can achieve this with a normal flathead provided it's small enough

I took some pictures as well to help anyone who's stuck.

[nZtiZia]

well done!

[smomin23]

Originally Posted by nZtiZia

well done!

Lol appreciate it! Can't believe such a simple mod took this long to get through but glad it's done

[jg05]

“Firstly, I want to apologize for not posting yesterday. I got the rubber on time but couldn't get make time to take a whack at it.”

Perhaps the funniest line of this thread!

Seriously, Glad you got it working,

[smomin23]

Originally Posted by jg05

"Firstly, I want to apologize for not posting yesterday. I got the rubber on time but couldn't get make time to take a whack at it."

Perhaps the funniest line of this thread!

Seriously, Glad you got it working,

Didn't realize this little innuendo till you pointed it out! Needed a good laugh

[stockli81]

Something I didn't even notice... So if you have the glass crystal controls, the volume knob is not the same?

[nZtiZia]

Originally Posted by stockli81

Something I didn't even notice... So if you have the glass crystal controls, the volume knob is not the same?

that's what happened with MY21 G05. MY20 G05 included the crystal volume button, especially in EU

[ksavostin]

Originally Posted by stockli81

Something I didn't even notice... So if you have the glass crystal controls, the volume knob is not the same?

Correct, even if you have an executive package with the glass control the volume button is a just a black plastic piece.

[Stoshu]

Well I give this a try next!

[smomin23]

Originally Posted by Stoshu

Well I give this a try next!

Fully worth it. It's the smallest thing but every time I look down I see my set completed and it's a nice feeling.

The old button didn't take anything away from the interior but this feels like it adds.

[ksavostin]

Originally Posted by smomin23

Fully worth it. It's the smallest thing but every time I look down I see my set completed and it's a nice feeling.

The old button didn't take anything away from the interior but this feels like it adds.

Thanks, changed mines today in 10 minutes, took ring off same way as on the video, then used as you suggested screw driver.

[smomin23]

Originally Posted by ksavostin

Thanks, changed mines today in 10 minutes, took ring off same way as on the video, then used as you suggested screw driver.

Lookin' good my man!

[otommytruongo]

What i did was drill small hole in middle then used a eyeglass screw driver to pop it out from the middle hole. Very easy instead of prying around the button it will cause scratch or dent around the metal housing

[mumpers]

2nd otommytruongo...did this on my 2021 X5 in a couple minutes by just drilling a small hole in the center of the button and used a small pick through the hole and pry back in the direction of the L..popped right off

[stockli81]

Where did everyone order this piece from? Was it an OEM part?

[nZtiZia]

Originally Posted by stockli81

Where did everyone order this piece from? Was it an OEM part?

assuming you're in the U.S., you can get it from Car Analysis. It is OEM, but I couldn't order it from the site, so I contacted them to send me a PayPal invoice.

[smomin23]

Guys another method Martin provided:

1. Heat the end of a hot glue stick with a lighter and affix to volume button. Be careful to only get the button, not the trim

2. Hold it in place as it cools

3. Pull

I realize we have many different methods on here at this point but more options never hurt

Honestly the support from this company is fantastic. I don't know about you guys but I intend to tell anyone in my circle about them.

You support the forum, the forum supports you.

[ksavostin]

Originally Posted by stockli81

Where did everyone order this piece from? Was it an OEM part?

I bought it here:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1

[stockli81]

Just swapped mine out, 2 minutes whole process... Opted to drill hole through the regular volume button, used a small thin allen wrench through hole and popped it out from the left side. New crystal button popped right in...

[OzzieJeff]

What did you use to drill the hole with?

Planning to do this mod after I take delivery next month.

Cheers!

[PNW Now]

for those that drilled a hole, did you first pry off the metal ring? or did you skip that step?