G05
BMW X5
155.6KVIEWS
353REPLIES
97APPRECIATES
136ACTIVE PEOPLE
03-06-2025LAST POST
10-09-2020
TheVazha wrote
Reading your posts, I will admit you guys are way smarter than I am.

What does the math look like on a lease vs finance vs purchase cash and sell three years later?

Obviously each has its own positives and negatives, but what's the smart money move?

Does your answer basically carry over to any car purchase? I've purchased all my cars cash and sometimes I recoup a good amount of my initial acquisition price, sometimes not. In most cases it's less than the cost of a lease but add the maintenance and it's probably an even wash.

Thoughts?
If you time it right, BMW leases tend to be very advantageous. Another thing is that the leases are transferrable so it is easy to get out of them. Unfortunately the X5M has never leased well since it is a low production vehicle.

The advantage of a lease is that the exit price is known at the end and you can choose to buy it out and sell it if resale prices are strong or just hand over the keys if they are weak or the car has been damaged.

Another advantage is that in some states like California you only pay tax on the monthly payment. This means with a 60% residual you only end up paying tax on 40% of the purchase price. This can be significant on a $125K truck.

I always do the math on lease vs purchase and decide that way. My Ram 2500 diesel was a purchase, but my M5 was a lease.
10-09-2020
Salespunk wrote
TheVazha wrote
Reading your posts, I will admit you guys are way smarter than I am.

What does the math look like on a lease vs finance vs purchase cash and sell three years later?

Obviously each has its own positives and negatives, but what's the smart money move?

Does your answer basically carry over to any car purchase? I've purchased all my cars cash and sometimes I recoup a good amount of my initial acquisition price, sometimes not. In most cases it's less than the cost of a lease but add the maintenance and it's probably an even wash.

Thoughts?
If you time it right, BMW leases tend to be very advantageous. Another thing is that the leases are transferrable so it is easy to get out of them. Unfortunately the X5M has never leased well since it is a low production vehicle.

The advantage of a lease is that the exit price is known at the end and you can choose to buy it out and sell it if resale prices are strong or just hand over the keys if they are weak or the car has been damaged.

Another advantage is that in some states like California you only pay tax on the monthly payment. This means with a 60% residual you only end up paying tax on 40% of the purchase price. This can be significant on a $125K truck.

I always do the math on lease vs purchase and decide that way. My Ram 2500 diesel was a purchase, but my M5 was a lease.
Awesome thank you for the great advice.

I went to look at a 2020 E63S and I got quoted a lease that would cost me $100K over three years, with a residual of about $70k. I don't know how to negotiate car leases or purchases for that matter so I did the rough math and I realized I should probably leave the dealership. Which I did. Of course I got the obligatory call an hour later from the manager telling me they can drop the price by $6K to $119K. It still seemed like they were preparing for insertion and no indication of courtesy reach around.

I can't do it, I need to stick to buying lease returns at 55% of sticker price. 😢
10-13-2020
allen3ybq wrote
pookiemalibu wrote
UPDATE:

Dealer emails and pulls some bullsh*t about BMWFS won't approve without $10,500 down. Mind you, this is after I've paid a ~$3000 first month/deposit that's DAS, engaged vehicle transport service (should be able to get that $ back) AND made provisions for the turn-in of my current lease.

Dealer was supposed to refund my deposit yesterday, now I've got to wait for the finance manager and it will be Monday or Tuesday. So frustrating! If you hadn't run the credit app, why take the first month and deposit? Just wasted two weeks w/ this nonsense.

C'est Bimmer la vie.
Really sounds like some BS is going on
I need to preface this with saying I am not a lease broker, however, in relation to comments above, LeaseHckr totally changed my perspective on leasing.

I have my local dealership who I've bought my M5 in 2015, leased a 2018 X5M at the end of 17 (due up in a few weeks), and after shopping around I was between an RS7 and another X5M. I have also serviced both of my cars here religiously and have a great relationship.

The RS7 is so exclusive right now that it just didn't make sense.

I went to my dealer who had a X5M Comp just how I wanted it ($123,795 sticker) and asked for numbers on 15k/36mo.

They came back at 4% off, a jacked up money factor and quoted it at $1,876 with $2750 down. I knew there were deals out there for less so I went on LeaseHckr to see what the real numbers were.

At 10k/36mo, base money factor (for October @ 0.00082) and what has been pretty standard across the board at 10% off, you should be at around $1,350 before taxes with no money down and no MSDs.

I sent my dealer the spreadsheet of the real numbers and asked what games they were playing and if they could match these numbers as I'd really like to give them the business, and they came back and said we can do an additional $500 off. I laughed and they pretty much said go pound sand.

I paid a lease broker $500 and I didn't even need to talk to the dealership, got a build slot for November on a MY21 and customized it just how I wanted, and am doing Spartanburg Delivery in December. At 15k/36mo with taxes, W&T & lease end protection, I'm right around $1,575 with no money down and no MSDs.
10-16-2020
Have a lead on a 2021 F95 in the Midwest. Approx. 9.5% off. PM me and I can forward you the info.
10-19-2020
TheVazha wrote
I can't do it, I need to stick to buying lease returns at 55% of sticker price. 😢
True, but there is nothing like getting a brand new vehicle. :)
10-22-2020
I have a friend who is offering 1 build slot for an x6m at 9% off. If anyone is interested, message me and I'll send contact info.
10-25-2020
botis1028 wrote
allen3ybq wrote
pookiemalibu wrote
UPDATE:

Dealer emails and pulls some bullsh*t about BMWFS won't approve without $10,500 down. Mind you, this is after I've paid a ~$3000 first month/deposit that's DAS, engaged vehicle transport service (should be able to get that $ back) AND made provisions for the turn-in of my current lease.

Dealer was supposed to refund my deposit yesterday, now I've got to wait for the finance manager and it will be Monday or Tuesday. So frustrating! If you hadn't run the credit app, why take the first month and deposit? Just wasted two weeks w/ this nonsense.

C'est Bimmer la vie.
Really sounds like some BS is going on
I need to preface this with saying I am not a lease broker, however, in relation to comments above, LeaseHckr totally changed my perspective on leasing.

I have my local dealership who I've bought my M5 in 2015, leased a 2018 X5M at the end of 17 (due up in a few weeks), and after shopping around I was between an RS7 and another X5M. I have also serviced both of my cars here religiously and have a great relationship.

The RS7 is so exclusive right now that it just didn't make sense.

I went to my dealer who had a X5M Comp just how I wanted it ($123,795 sticker) and asked for numbers on 15k/36mo.

They came back at 4% off, a jacked up money factor and quoted it at $1,876 with $2750 down. I knew there were deals out there for less so I went on LeaseHckr to see what the real numbers were.

At 10k/36mo, base money factor (for October @ 0.00082) and what has been pretty standard across the board at 10% off, you should be at around $1,350 before taxes with no money down and no MSDs.

I sent my dealer the spreadsheet of the real numbers and asked what games they were playing and if they could match these numbers as I'd really like to give them the business, and they came back and said we can do an additional $500 off. I laughed and they pretty much said go pound sand.

I paid a lease broker $500 and I didn't even need to talk to the dealership, got a build slot for November on a MY21 and customized it just how I wanted, and am doing Spartanburg Delivery in December. At 15k/36mo with taxes, W&T & lease end protection, I'm right around $1,575 with no money down and no MSDs.
botis1028 wrote
allen3ybq wrote
pookiemalibu wrote
UPDATE:

Dealer emails and pulls some bullsh*t about BMWFS won't approve without $10,500 down. Mind you, this is after I've paid a ~$3000 first month/deposit that's DAS, engaged vehicle transport service (should be able to get that $ back) AND made provisions for the turn-in of my current lease.

Dealer was supposed to refund my deposit yesterday, now I've got to wait for the finance manager and it will be Monday or Tuesday. So frustrating! If you hadn't run the credit app, why take the first month and deposit? Just wasted two weeks w/ this nonsense.

C'est Bimmer la vie.
Really sounds like some BS is going on
I need to preface this with saying I am not a lease broker, however, in relation to comments above, LeaseHckr totally changed my perspective on leasing.

I have my local dealership who I've bought my M5 in 2015, leased a 2018 X5M at the end of 17 (due up in a few weeks), and after shopping around I was between an RS7 and another X5M. I have also serviced both of my cars here religiously and have a great relationship.

The RS7 is so exclusive right now that it just didn't make sense.

I went to my dealer who had a X5M Comp just how I wanted it ($123,795 sticker) and asked for numbers on 15k/36mo.

They came back at 4% off, a jacked up money factor and quoted it at $1,876 with $2750 down. I knew there were deals out there for less so I went on LeaseHckr to see what the real numbers were.

At 10k/36mo, base money factor (for October @ 0.00082) and what has been pretty standard across the board at 10% off, you should be at around $1,350 before taxes with no money down and no MSDs.

I sent my dealer the spreadsheet of the real numbers and asked what games they were playing and if they could match these numbers as I'd really like to give them the business, and they came back and said we can do an additional $500 off. I laughed and they pretty much said go pound sand.

I paid a lease broker $500 and I didn't even need to talk to the dealership, got a build slot for November on a MY21 and customized it just how I wanted, and am doing Spartanburg Delivery in December. At 15k/36mo with taxes, W&T & lease end protection, I'm right around $1,575 with no money down and no MSDs.
Could you PM me your brokers info??
10-27-2020
Does anybody know a dealer in SoCal that would sell for 9% off?

Trying to stay local but having a hard time finding a deal.

Thanks.
10-27-2020
bmwman3241 wrote
Does anybody know a dealer in SoCal that would sell for 9% off?

Trying to stay local but having a hard time finding a deal.

Thanks.
PM me if you want my broker's info. He's got great relationships in SoCal. Just finalized a great deal on an 21 M8GC comp yesterday at triple net for me.
11-04-2020
Updated with November program figures.
11-04-2020
Jason wrote
Updated with November program figures.
Jason wrote
Updated with November program figures.
Did anything change?
11-09-2020
Hi guys, I'm in Oregon and I'm looking for a 20/21 X5m Comp. I'm not having much luck locating a BMW broker in my area, please PM me if anyone knows of any. Thanks!
11-19-2020
Jason wrote
Please use this thread as a master thread to discuss quotes, pricing, lease program, and the like.

This first post will be updated monthly with the latest lease program numbers (residuals, credits, incentives).

Please do not make dealer / salesperson recommendations or referrals in this thread. Thank you!

Please note that the incentives may differ in your local area.


November 2020 Lease Program:

X5M and X5M Competition (2021MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit






X5M and X5M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit
[/QUOTE
11-19-2020
Jason wrote
Please use this thread as a master thread to discuss quotes, pricing, lease program, and the like.

This first post will be updated monthly with the latest lease program numbers (residuals, credits, incentives).

Please do not make dealer / salesperson recommendations or referrals in this thread. Thank you!

Please note that the incentives may differ in your local area.


November 2020 Lease Program:

X5M and X5M Competition (2021MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit






X5M and X5M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit
I’m eyeing a 2021 X6M which I would lease between now and the first week of December. Do you think the rates would stay the same, get worst, or work in my favor for December?
11-20-2020
Firstm31993 wrote
I'm eyeing a 2021 X6M which I would lease between now and the first week of December. Do you think the rates would stay the same, get worst, or work in my favor for December?
The dealer should able to switch between Nov and Dec rate, whichever is better when you pick up the car. But you have to lock the Nov rate in order to keep it.
11-20-2020
Silververtu wrote
Firstm31993 wrote
I'm eyeing a 2021 X6M which I would lease between now and the first week of December. Do you think the rates would stay the same, get worst, or work in my favor for December?
The dealer should able to switch to between Nov and Dec rate, whichever is better when you pick up the car. But you have to lock the Nov rate in order to keep it.
Thank you.

I'm currently in the 5th day of the final stage 3 lease assumption. Im told it would generally take approximately 3-5 weeks start to finish, but due to COVID BMWFS gives an approximate time of 14 days to complete. If I can get my email of complete between now and before the end of November, then I'll be clear to try locking in the X6M and not have to worry about my current lease vehicle. The vehicle will have been officially turned over to a new owner. Hopefully BMWFS finishes earlier then they say.
11-25-2020
I ordered this car...it was not sitting on the lot.

How'd I do on this lease for a 2021 x5m competition:

$118,695 retail.
$114,267.93 sales price
$122,734.18 total price, including fees, taxes, registration, etc.

$0 down.
$1,752 per month
36 month lease, 10k per year.
11-25-2020
geared wrote
I ordered this car...it was not sitting on the lot.

How'd I do on this lease for a 2021 x5m competition:

$118,695 retail.
$114,267.93 sales price
$122,734.18 total price, including fees, taxes, registration, etc.

$0 down.
$1,752 per month
36 month lease, 10k per year.
Looks like only 4-5% off. Can get you 10% off from an East coast dealer if you are willing to pay for shipping. PM me. They would have to look for an allocation.
11-25-2020
Jason wrote
Please use this thread as a master thread to discuss quotes, pricing, lease program, and the like.

This first post will be updated monthly with the latest lease program numbers (residuals, credits, incentives).

Please do not make dealer / salesperson recommendations or referrals in this thread. Thank you!

Please note that the incentives may differ in your local area.


November 2020 Lease Program:

X5M and X5M Competition (2021MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 52% residual
12k miles / 54% residual
10k miles / 55% residual
$1000 loyalty credit






X5M and X5M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit


X6M and X6M Competition (2020MY)
15k miles / 51% residual
12k miles / 53% residual
10k miles / 54% residual
$1000 loyalty credit
Do we know what the residual is for 2021 X6M @ 7500 miles/year?

thanks in advance
11-30-2020
Came in for some regular service and spotted this in the showroom. It's gotta be the best deal I've seen so far on an M model. It's got 105 miles on it at the moment.

Located at Global Imports BMW Atlanta.
An image attached to this post, provided by the posterAn image attached to this post, provided by the poster
11-30-2020
SHARMAATL wrote
Came in for some regular service and spotted this in the showroom. It's gotta be the best deal I've seen so far on an M model. It's got 105 miles on it at the moment.

Located at Global Imports BMW Atlanta.
That's a simple and attractive deal
12-01-2020
Jason wrote
Updated with November program figures.
Hello, Any changes for the December lease rates for X6m?