G05
BMW X5
187KVIEWS
296REPLIES
139APPRECIATES
79ACTIVE PEOPLE
05-14-2026LAST POST
05-08-2020
Hi has anyone just done the X pipe resonator replacement and the exhaust flap mod? If yes how's the sound?
05-09-2020
M50iX5 wrote
Hi has anyone just done the X pipe resonator replacement and the exhaust flap mod? If yes how's the sound?
I will do only downpipes first then decide if I want to remove the stock resonator. I will post vids after. My hope would be in the next month or two. ARM has a catless downpipe for crazy cheap, but they do not have any bracket for the pipe. That means the exhaust front is hanging on the downpipe which is now hanging on the turbo v-band. I am not sure if I am comfortable with that or not. I am still debating that.
05-09-2020
130FeetDeep wrote
888RRE wrote
See below the detailed photos. I am very happy with it.
The only thing is that if you do downpipes in the future, this will be obnoxiously loud.
I did this on my modified M50i :). OPFs out, replaced the cats with two 200cell ones. Damn, it'a loud and a little bit drony at 3-4k rpms. Sounds like the concept M8 Competition on youtube.
I will reinstall only the OEM mid-resonators
05-09-2020
x5m50i wrote
I did this on my modified M50i :). OPFs out, replaced the cats with two 200cell ones. Damn, it'a loud and a little bit drony at 3-4k rpms. Sounds like the concept M8 Competition on youtube.
I will reinstall only the OEM mid-resonators
That is exactly why I am keeping those resonators for now.
05-09-2020
888RRE wrote
See below the detailed photos. I am very happy with it.
Nice job. What was the inside diameter of the piping you used?? 2.5 inches??
05-09-2020
I took out the resonator and tap welded the flaps to always stay open
05-09-2020
Tim2189 wrote
I took out the resonator and tap welded the flaps to always stay open
every cold start makes me smile
05-10-2020
Except your neighbors won't be lol....
05-11-2020
Alan l. wrote
Except your neighbors won't be lol....
Luckily I live in a building with outside parking lot
I cant imagine having this set up living in a house or suburbs
06-30-2020
Tim2189 wrote
I took out the resonator and tap welded the flaps to always stay open
Great sound! Any noticeable drone on highway or normal driving?
07-01-2020
Tim2189 wrote
I took out the resonator and tap welded the flaps to always stay open
Have you ever tried a cold start in sport mode? :)
07-01-2020
hkleyman wrote
Tim2189 wrote
I took out the resonator and tap welded the flaps to always stay open
Have you ever tried a cold start in sport mode? :)
Yup that's exactly what that video is haha
07-24-2020
888RRE wrote
here is the launch, will try upload the revving shortly
Is this video with streight pipes or x pipe? Hows the drone inside with x pipe.
07-27-2020
straight pipes, not sure how the X pipe would be any different.
07-27-2020
888RRE wrote
straight pipes, not sure how the X pipe would be any different.
So I have a 50i and was planning on doing this exact thing, delete resonator and install straight pipes. Just curious, if you and other don't mind sharing what they paid for to do that? I'm in NY and I'm looking at pricing with some shops. Also, is that stainless steel? Does it make a difference stainless or not?

Thanks
07-29-2020
G050i wrote
So I have a 50i and was planning on doing this exact thing, delete resonator and install straight pipes. Just curious, if you and other don't mind sharing what they paid for to do that? I'm in NY and I'm looking at pricing with some shops. Also, is that stainless steel? Does it make a difference stainless or not?

Thanks
I got my resonator delete done at joeys diagnostics on Hylan Blvd in Staten Island, paid around 200-250
They are a specialty muffler shop so i'm sure you can find cheaper if you wanted
07-29-2020
G050i wrote
So I have a 50i and was planning on doing this exact thing, delete resonator and install straight pipes. Just curious, if you and other don't mind sharing what they paid for to do that? I'm in NY and I'm looking at pricing with some shops. Also, is that stainless steel? Does it make a difference stainless or not?

Thanks
07-30-2020
Tim2189 wrote
Thanks for sharing what you paid. That was around what I thought it would be too.

Did you do x or straight?

And it could be me or maybe the 2nd video you sent was from further away but the first video you shared of the cold start sounds way different than this last one. Is it me? Just sounds more subdued on the initial start for some reason.
07-30-2020
G050i wrote
Tim2189 wrote
Thanks for sharing what you paid. That was around what I thought it would be too.

Did you do x or straight?

And it could be me or maybe the 2nd video you sent was from further away but the first video you shared of the cold start sounds way different than this last one. Is it me? Just sounds more subdued on the initial start for some reason.
The 2nd video I had the car running an hour prior. The first video it cooled off overnight so it had a much louder start up
I did straight pipe resonator delete
07-30-2020
I've been seriously thinking about doing this since the very first post.

Seriously concerned about DRONE inside the cabin at highway speeds. Rather than going straight pipe or X-pipe.... I was actually thinking about doing an old-school H-pipe instead, and shooting for that "muscle car" sound. Same concerns though..... Drone.
07-30-2020
Ninefourteener wrote
I've been seriously thinking about doing this since the very first post.

Seriously concerned about DRONE inside the cabin at highway speeds. Rather than going straight pipe or X-pipe.... I was actually thinking about doing an old-school H-pipe instead, and shooting for that "muscle car" sound. Same concerns though..... Drone.
Honestly I dont notice any drone, then again im always in sports plus manually shifting city or highway so I wouldn't really notice it.
08-04-2020
G050i wrote
So I have a 50i and was planning on doing this exact thing, delete resonator and install straight pipes. Just curious, if you and other don't mind sharing what they paid for to do that? I'm in NY and I'm looking at pricing with some shops. Also, is that stainless steel? Does it make a difference stainless or not?

Thanks
I paid $300 AUD